Fall Vs. Spring Planting Pros And Cons

By Darcy Larum | March 19, 2019 Co Author: Tonya Barnett
Image by amenic181
by Darcy Larum
March 19, 2019
and Tonya Barnett

For many gardeners, deciding when flower and vegetable seeds should be planted into the garden can lead to frustration. Learning how to best meet the needs and growing requirements of various types of plants often involves careful research and attention to local conditions within one’s own garden.

While some plants may grow well when planted in the spring, others may thrive when planted in the fall. Deciding upon the season in which to plant could be the determining factor that most greatly impacts the yield of crops within the garden. Here we will present both sides – reasons for sowing seeds in spring and autumn seed planting.

Fall Planting Pros – Reasons to Plant in Fall

(Tonya’s viewpoint) While most gardeners are familiar with planting during the spring, there are actually many fall planting pros to consider. Here are just some of the reasons to plant in fall:

Easier to grow cool climate plants. Growers who experience high heat, humidity, and other adverse conditions throughout the summer season may often have great difficulty growing cool season crops. For this reason, many gardeners consider fall planting in both the vegetable garden and in hardy annual flower beds. Vegetables such as broccoli, cauliflower, spinach, and lettuce are just a few examples of cold tolerant plants. Fall planting not only extends the vegetable garden harvest into winter, but also allows plants to mature under more optimal growing conditions.

Improves overall growth. Additional reasons to plant in the fall are directly related to the overall growth habits of the plants. Hardy annual flowers, which are resistant to frost in certain growing zones, may also be planted in the fall. When planted at this time, flowering plants continue to become established throughout the winter and into the early spring. This period of growth results in plants that are overall larger and more robust before they begin to bloom in the spring. Certain cold tolerant herbs, such as chamomile, also benefit from fall plantings in much the same manner.

Seeds germinate better. Growers advocate for autumn seed planting for many reasons, including the ease at which seeds are able to germinate. Fall weather patterns, which include increased rainfall and cooler temperatures, contribute to conditions which promote the germination of seeds. Seedlings are also able to become better established as decreased temperatures and decreased insect pressure allow for a greater chance of survival and stress free growth.

Why Plant in Spring vs. Fall

(Darcy’s viewpoint) Whether you’re looking for grass, vegetables or ornamental plant seeds, in the springtime you’ll find seed aisles at nearly any store. Sowing seeds in spring is traditional, and spring planting pros abound.

It’s only natural. Spring is a time of new beginnings, fertility, birth and growth. Days grow longer, as the sun moves closer to us, warming the earth beneath our feet. The warming soil and springtime rain spurs germination in the dormant seeds from last fall and new life bursts out. Mimicking the natural cycles of growth, farmers and gardeners have sown seed in spring for thousands of years.

More options and availability. While certain plants do prefer to be sown in fall or winter, generally most plants will grow well when planted in spring and it is easier to obtain seed or young plants. In fact, many nurseries, garden centers and other stores only carry seed or seed starting equipment in the springtime. The nursery stock at garden centers and nurseries also tends to become sparser after spring. You may miss out if you put your planting projects off until autumn.

More time to prep the garden. Why plant in spring? Tradition and availability aside, planting in spring also allows us adequate time to properly prepare our garden beds, while also giving plants a nice long season to grow, mature, bloom and seed before winter.

Winter chill helps limit pests. In northern climates, fall planting may not be an option because of early frosts and freezes. However, these frosts and freezes kill off weeds, insect pests and even some diseases, giving us a clean slate in spring.

Sowing Seeds in Spring vs. Fall

While the decision of when to start seeds may vary depending upon where one lives, there is no doubt that there are positives and negatives to planting in both fall and spring. By familiarizing oneself with particular plant growth habits, growers are able to better access the timing needed at planting time. This, in tandem with routine garden care, will reward gardeners with bountiful vegetable harvests and an abundance of spring and early summer flowers – regardless of when you plant.

Tell us what you think: Leave a comment
6 people are already talking about this.
This article was last updated on
Read more about Gardening Pros and Cons
Did you find this helpful? Share it with your friends!

Get our latest eBook, “Bring Your Garden Indoors: 13 DIY Projects for the Fall and Winter”

As the seasons change, it’s time to think about bringing your garden indoors. From creating an indoor garden to using natural decor for your holiday decorations, our latest eBook features 13 of our favorite DIY projects for the whole family.

 Happy holidays from all of us at Gardening Know How.

  • A. Jordan
    Comment added September 2, 2022Reply

    I agree, the article is pretty much useless without more specifics. Where, and with what plants, does it work to plant in the fall? Where and with what plants is it best to plant in spring? It does not compute that planting in the fall is simply a choice based on opinion...

  • Linda Caylor
    Comment added August 28, 2022Reply

    This article was pretty much useless.

    • Brenda
      Comment added September 2, 2022Reply

      Agree. . .

  • B. Trap
    Comment added August 28, 2022Reply

    fall vs spring.
    Give us a list for both. We have heard the talk, show the bottom line results for different areas of the country.

  • Linda Bury
    Comment added September 9, 2020Reply

    I agree with Pat. It would be useful to know which plants/bulbs we are best sewing now?

  • Pat Maguire
    Comment added September 6, 2020Reply

    All very well giving pros and cons, but doesnt help amature gardeners. We need advise on what is best to do now. What should we be planting and how. i.e. what kind of veg can I sew now?

Leave a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Join Us - Sign up to get all the latest gardening tips!